Re: Bad Stuff About Baka Tsuki
Posted: Fri Jun 14, 2013 3:58 am
so, where's you homeland?
.....................................-sobs-..........DAMN YOU!!!Zero2001 wrote:I'm there right nowNura rihan wrote:I just like UK and I want to go there someday .
Where is Florza when you need him??? this proves that i am not the only guy connected with UK and South AsiaZero2001 wrote:South Asian Subcontinent
I aprove tat, let's talk about good stuffZero2001 wrote:Who cares about bad stuff. Let's pull a 180° and talk about the good stuff!
Besides it's depressing to talk about the bad things all the time. Life should be filled with more happiness.
I just found out which mogu this is from.pudding321 wrote:Feel free to quote anyone's words you find on the net that speak badly about baka-tsuki here. Please don't include the speaker's name and the website you find it.
either the Baka-Tsuki translator stopped giving a shit or someone else translated this chapter, because the translation they have up there is terrible. Not only have they completely forgone any sense of style, they also made numerous translation mistakes in meaning (propositional content).
AND,this here is someone defending Baka-tsuki..this guy deserves a hug from our loliDespite its cliches, childishness, and the fact that just about every single character is a recycled stereotype, it still manages to be an enjoyable read, provided you can manage to accept its gaping flaws.
Warning: The translation is quite bad. Understandable? Yes. Eloquent? No.
My comment about its translation was a mere "I calls em as I sees em" statement. Whether or not he put in a lot of effort in it by him/herself (which I commend him/her for) it doesn't take away from from its lack of flow in dialogue, general grammatical, spelling, and punctuation mistakes.
someone reviewing Bti can't believe you even said that. The translation is quite bad? The whole project was started from one person who devoted their spare time to translating the novel. If its so bad you should probably stop reading it. If you want something eloquent read plato. People translate for free during their spare time and this is on baka-tsuki unless you've done something for this community i wouldn't be criticizing others.
moreIf you want to read fan translated ones online Baka-Tsuki hosts a few.
Pros: it's set up like a wiki so if you spot spelling or grammar/translation errors you can edit them. Cons: many books are only partially translated and translators are often bad at grammar and readability.
and the last one.BakaTsuki isn't a fansub group though. People just upload their work onto BT.
The quality of oreimo on BT is such that NanoDesu is bitching on it however
I kind of wonder why the translation of Hyakka Ryouran Samurai Girls stopped on Baka-Tsuki, the translator hayashi_s most likely had personal or real life situations so I respect that if that is the reason or maybe the Light Novel was a bit too much fan service and not enough story? Just curious.Translators have a similar life span to slime. Majority of the translators get alienated, get tired or just quit cause its too annoying. Fan-translating is demanding. Maybe he started it disliked the series and quit? In the end its better to learn and read it yourself cause its "their" own personal interpretation.
Sir, "when they actually have quite a bit of good quality stuff" won't save you. It's like saying a polluted river has a few drops of clean water. And, oh, should you happen to read my post, you can rant or flame all you want. I'm immune to this type of thing anyway.リンペイ on June 2, 2013 at 6:03 am said:
ND will never be the same as B-T.
We actually have standards.
Reply ↓
He who escaped the Asylum on June 4, 2013 at 7:35 pm said:
Not all of what B-T does is crap.
Just some of it…. maybe half…. maybe more.
But they really shouldn’t let it stay crap, like they have a tendency to do.
That’s why their infamous for having naught but crap, when they actually have quite a bit of good quality stuff.
Its that they don’t challenge their translators to be better, like Nano does.
And from that, you get crap.
i posted one good thing about BT though..Zero2001 wrote:I understand. Well maybe not to the point of killing. But yeah, I get what you mean.
Update to previous post. Please check.