ばか！バカ！　馬鹿ー月！

This is the feed back thread for Seitokai no Ichizon at http://www.baka-tsuki.org/project/index ... no_Ichizon

Please tell us what you think of it.

it was good one, i heard the novel is quite different from the anime and manga ver?
well i was wonder if there would be more of this novel "seitokai no ichizon".
especially since i read that the protagonist was ranked one on the novel character(or something within that line, i hear that from sankakucomplex)
hope there would be more as soon as possible ^^

echimaru wrote:it was good one, i heard the novel is quite different from the anime and manga ver?
well i was wonder if there would be more of this novel "seitokai no ichizon".
especially since i read that the protagonist was ranked one on the novel character(or something within that line, i hear that from sankakucomplex)
hope there would be more as soon as possible ^^

Manga seemed quite bad in my opinion... too many words... but that cant be blamed...

The anime included a lot more parodies... not sure if its considered good or bad, but i can accept both anime and novel.

oddly enough i adore the manga. i find the drawing style actually better than the anime since it is based on moe-blob

I actually got into the anime after hearing about this series, and my multilingual friends have filled me with expectations of the novels. I hope this does get translated, it looks like it would be an interesting read.

I'm for it. And you know you have me as an editor when I have time. I was thinking of fixing the teasers, but if the real thing gets translated, I'll wait for those so I can do it all at once.

Why did my post have to be approved?

Dan wrote:Why did my post have to be approved?

I have no idea, that's odd.

Dan wrote:Why did my post have to be approved?

I think its because your not listed as a project editor or some rank higher

Since I'm almost finished with toradora, I'm considering taking up seitokai next year after toradora's completed. So I guess we just need a supervisor then, since Dan's gonna be the editor o_O

dragonst wrote:Since I'm almost finished with toradora, I'm considering taking up seitokai next year after toradora's completed. So I guess we just need a supervisor then, since Dan's gonna be the editor o_O

Till then its still a teaser which can get gain feedback...

I really enjoyed the teasers, I hope it'll get continued.

dragonst wrote:So I guess we just need a supervisor then

Supervisors are useless (Toradora doesn't even have one )
But don't worry, if you are doing Seitokai no Ichizon I will upload the image gallery, add navigation bar, insert the pictures, check the formatting, etc

I just want to expand on to the 'supervisor is useless' part.

To me supervisor is useful only when you want to chase down translators who registered a long time ago but has not put in any material since then. In that case it is the supervisor's duty to 'chase them down'.

I woul so love a translation for this novel.