Page 1 of 8

Candidate Vote for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 12:49 am
by onizuka-gto
It has been brought to my attention that we might need a new sub-forum, hence a new poll shall be created to determine which two projects shall co-habitat this new space.

Please post in this topic the candidates you wish to be included in the poll, I will limit the candidates to a maximum of eight so please nominate wisely.

Polls will be initiated on this following Wednesday the 1st of February, which will conclude in exactly seven days from inception.

This post will be updated when possible.

Edit: Polls has been created, polls will end in one week.

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 1:25 am
by rock96
DenYuuDen/Itsuten.

They deserve it, after all.

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 1:26 am
by Teh_ping
rock96 wrote:DenYuuDen/Itsuten.

They deserve it, after all.
Just leave it as Kagami Takaya series lol. Treat this as a farewell gift for Larethian.

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 1:29 am
by stellarroze
Ditto on DenYuuDen and Itsuten / Kagami Takaya series . :D

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 2:07 am
by Cosmic Eagle
onizuka-gto wrote:It has been brought to my attention that we might need a new sub-forum, hence a new poll shall be created to determine which two projects shall co-habitat this new space.
Why?

If you ask me.....Monogatari or Eiji Mikage stuff

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 2:20 am
by hobogunner
Well, we don't want completed projects, and the most popular ones on the forum right now in the Auxiliary Brigades would be ItsuTen/DenYuuDen, Infinite Stratos, Baka-Test, High School DxD, Haganai, and Campione!.

I'll add a poll in with those titles after everyone agrees upon the titles that should be included.

(I personally absolutely agree about the ItsuTen/DenYuuDen idea, but we'll see how it goes.)

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 5:34 am
by Mystes
Denyuuden and Itsuten. Perfect match and too many threads in the Aux. Brigade. (Half-joking, of course.)

If it were possible, I'd like to restruct the HnA/SAO paring too...but let's talk bout this later.

Edit: Saw that IS was the third in the last sub-forum vote. Could we add another sub-forums? :mrgreen:

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 7:45 am
by larethian
It seems like I didn't even need to post. :lol:


I was actually going to ask for it later, with another two volumes worth of translations. Denyuuden / Itsuten is best grouped together not just because they are by the same author, but they have many similar ideas presented in different ways and in different settings, which can spawn many different kinds of discussions, including crossover discussion. Fans (outside of BT) have often been discussing about who is more hax: Dark Rabbit or Solver of All Equations. :lol:

Similarly, it'll be good if SAO is grouped with Accel World, and Index is grouped with Heavy Object.

(Yes, I did the 'too many threads' thing on purpose, though the volume polls are for satisfying my personal curiosity)

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 8:05 am
by Teh_ping
Sort them by authors? I won't mind, but there'll be quite a shuffle. And CSR's pretty popular too, so they need a space, so I would prefer that if possible, Heavy Object joins the CSR/Index sub-forum. (Do we have a need for Nogizaka Haruka now?)

...Or you can sort them into a sub-forum called series worked on by Teh Ping because there's just too many...

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 10:12 am
by 13man18
I vote for Haganai or High School DxD. I would personally go with series that are still being translated.

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 12:37 pm
by Mystes
Teh_ping wrote:Sort them by authors? I won't mind, but there'll be quite a shuffle. And CSR's pretty popular too, so they need a space, so I would prefer that if possible, Heavy Object joins the CSR/Index sub-forum. (Do we have a need for Nogizaka Haruka now?)
For restructure:

-Denyuuden/Itsuten
-Index/Heavy Object
-CLANNAD out to the aux. forums
-Nogizaka Haruka with Campione
-SAO/Accel World
-Baka-Test/Haganai
-HnA/IS
-DxD a loner (too many people :lol: )

And no, Ping, for your little suggestion. You'll have make a cut in the entire forums for that. Can't squeeze in 5+ projects, can't we? :lol:

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 4:30 pm
by hobogunner
Now that I actually read Oni's post, I resisted the temptation to add in a poll. :roll: (Also, shouldn't we try to avoid going off topic with this one.....though, maybe we could make a "Ping's Brigade" and have subforums.)

Any other ideas aside from ItsuTen/DenYuuDen, Infinite Stratos, Baka-Test, High School DxD, Haganai, Campione!, and the Monogatari series?

Also, what happens if the polling grows into the Ping's next project poll broken-ness? Do we default to actual posts?

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 6:53 pm
by Kadi
Does Campione really need its own subforum? Most of the discussion is done by Kira, Ichigo and me, and for terminology 1 extra thread is enough. An extra thread that hasn't brought the results I wanted it to so that I've gone on and started bothering people directly through PMs... I think Campione is alright in the AuxBrigades until we have some more content or more people discussing it, but that's not going to happen any time soon.

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2012 10:48 pm
by cboy123
High School DxD since it was too popular

Re: Candidate for New Sub-Forum [Poll]

Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2012 1:43 am
by chancs
I would say :

i. Itsuten
ii. DxD :D

even Legendary heroes

in short...those having max hits/updates