Re: My theory about the rise of Sasaki
Posted: Thu Mar 13, 2008 8:37 pm
something just lit up in my head.. do try and bear with me as my thoughts are a bit muddled right now..
the following is an excerpt from v4:
kyon's rationalization of yuki's action is quite accurate, for a normal human being observing an alien that is.. also, the fact that kyon is rather naive led to his excluding any possible romantic inclinations as motivation for yuki. but something struck me as odd; yuki did theoretically grant kyon total freedom and responsibility for his actions, but the universe she created for him goes directly against how haruhiverse works.
as an analogy, think of haruhi drawing the tanabata message with 3-years-from-the-future kyon, and 3-years++-from-the-future kyon reminding haruhi to take care of john smith. now we go to yuki-verse; accdg to kyon's POV, he was transported to there on Dec.18, spent some two days, then went back 3 years to fulfill his second duty to haruhi. after which he goes back to haruhi-verse as yuki-verse was just being created, to have yuki deal away with her personal world, and let reality run its course once more. if yuki had in mind the rules of STC, it should have followed that kyon was never transported to yuki-verse in the first place, as he interrupted the progress of said universe.
to further complicate things, koizumi led kyon into believing that yuki just messed up with time - via using Bernoulli's lemniscate as an illustration. even yuki herself told kyon that it was her temporal converter that did this. it seems more like yuki created a universe of her own, rather than just tamper with the timeline.. or if i am allowed a bit of leeway, i would say that for the two days kyon stayed in the yuki-verse, was all an illusion, that ended the moment he hit the Enter key (think Matrix, if you will). the IDSE isn't as powerful as we believe them to be, they themselves suppose that they can evolve into something more via haruhi. the fact that they exist beyond space and time doesn't give them the ability to tamper with it freely. rather, it is easier to imagine them transferring a person's consciousness into a matrix of sorts, lead the person into believing he/she is still experiencing reality.
this is how i imagine v4 to have actually run: Dec. 17 found the SOS-Dan planning for a Christmas party at the Lit. club room, after which the Dan went out to get more stuff - kyon's reindeer costume. we then have kyon falling headlong from the stairwell, losing consciousness until Dec. 21 as a result. yuki, having acquired kyon's consciousness, goes ahead into 'installing' him into a matrix, yet giving him a chance to escape the matrix, and subsequently transport him back to 3ya tanabata - this is what kyon and mikuru witnessed her doing come sunset when comatose-kyon was already at the hospital. after kyon accomplished his task of reminding haruhi, they went back to yuki's apartment, who then did something to them so that they can somehow 'travel' into yuki's matrix in their true forms - body and consciousness. after ryouko's 2nd death, and yuki's shutting down her matrix, mikuru led kyon through what 'really' happened while he was out cold, i.e. bringing him to the hospital.
to wrap up this pseudo-theory of mine, yuki's matrix runs alongside with reality, meaning there are two timelines that occurred, yet kyon is the only one who fully experienced them - mikuru only coming into the scene for repairing any damage caused by the timequake. those in reality were unaware of this, except for the time-travelers; they did not expressly tell kyon about it, but yuki's matrix was built to run alongside reality indefinitely, given that the Emergency Escape program had a time limit of 2 days, and that kyon's remaining in comatose indefinitely will have caused great changes to reality via haruhi - a timeline in which kyon was given up for dead.
sorry for the giga-post guys.. just had to get it out of my head, now to watch SHnY for the nth time..
the following is an excerpt from v4:
Spoiler! :
as an analogy, think of haruhi drawing the tanabata message with 3-years-from-the-future kyon, and 3-years++-from-the-future kyon reminding haruhi to take care of john smith. now we go to yuki-verse; accdg to kyon's POV, he was transported to there on Dec.18, spent some two days, then went back 3 years to fulfill his second duty to haruhi. after which he goes back to haruhi-verse as yuki-verse was just being created, to have yuki deal away with her personal world, and let reality run its course once more. if yuki had in mind the rules of STC, it should have followed that kyon was never transported to yuki-verse in the first place, as he interrupted the progress of said universe.
to further complicate things, koizumi led kyon into believing that yuki just messed up with time - via using Bernoulli's lemniscate as an illustration. even yuki herself told kyon that it was her temporal converter that did this. it seems more like yuki created a universe of her own, rather than just tamper with the timeline.. or if i am allowed a bit of leeway, i would say that for the two days kyon stayed in the yuki-verse, was all an illusion, that ended the moment he hit the Enter key (think Matrix, if you will). the IDSE isn't as powerful as we believe them to be, they themselves suppose that they can evolve into something more via haruhi. the fact that they exist beyond space and time doesn't give them the ability to tamper with it freely. rather, it is easier to imagine them transferring a person's consciousness into a matrix of sorts, lead the person into believing he/she is still experiencing reality.
this is how i imagine v4 to have actually run: Dec. 17 found the SOS-Dan planning for a Christmas party at the Lit. club room, after which the Dan went out to get more stuff - kyon's reindeer costume. we then have kyon falling headlong from the stairwell, losing consciousness until Dec. 21 as a result. yuki, having acquired kyon's consciousness, goes ahead into 'installing' him into a matrix, yet giving him a chance to escape the matrix, and subsequently transport him back to 3ya tanabata - this is what kyon and mikuru witnessed her doing come sunset when comatose-kyon was already at the hospital. after kyon accomplished his task of reminding haruhi, they went back to yuki's apartment, who then did something to them so that they can somehow 'travel' into yuki's matrix in their true forms - body and consciousness. after ryouko's 2nd death, and yuki's shutting down her matrix, mikuru led kyon through what 'really' happened while he was out cold, i.e. bringing him to the hospital.
to wrap up this pseudo-theory of mine, yuki's matrix runs alongside with reality, meaning there are two timelines that occurred, yet kyon is the only one who fully experienced them - mikuru only coming into the scene for repairing any damage caused by the timequake. those in reality were unaware of this, except for the time-travelers; they did not expressly tell kyon about it, but yuki's matrix was built to run alongside reality indefinitely, given that the Emergency Escape program had a time limit of 2 days, and that kyon's remaining in comatose indefinitely will have caused great changes to reality via haruhi - a timeline in which kyon was given up for dead.
sorry for the giga-post guys.. just had to get it out of my head, now to watch SHnY for the nth time..