Page 1 of 1

Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 3:58 pm
by feRfe
Spoiler! :
“That doll’s true appearance is a bird greater than you in size. She once fell in love with a traveling cenobite, and together the two had spent many years working together to build a church. But no matter how many years went by, that doll would never age, and thus the cenobite grew suspicious. Surely you can guess how things developed after that?”

Perhaps he was just imagining things, but Lawrence seemed to feel Horo tighten the grip of her arms.

Lawrence felt that he seemed to understand the reason Deanna collected ancient legends and protected the alchemists.
I don't understand the reason. Anyone know?

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 7:30 pm
by Krikit
Spoiler! :
Well, the Cenobite that was building the churches can be assumed to have been a follower of the Church. Also assumed from this is that Deanara (spelling off) didn't reveal her true identity to him. So year after year as he got older and she didn't, he grew suspicious, and probably thought she was possesed by a demon, and tried to kill her or something....It's that kind of thing.

As for why she collects ancient legends and protects the alchemists....The only thing I can think of is....actually...I'm kind of at a loss on this one as well...haha. Maybe she thought the alchemists were the kind of people that, since they go against the church, are the only people who could ever 'maybe' accept her if they knew her true identity. As for the ancient legends, perhaps it's just to hear stories about dieties and humans that fall and love, and it works out.

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 11:52 pm
by salv87
Krikit wrote:
Spoiler! :
As for why she collects ancient legends and protects the alchemists....The only thing I can think of is....actually...I'm kind of at a loss on this one as well...haha. Maybe she thought the alchemists were the kind of people that, since they go against the church, are the only people who could ever 'maybe' accept her if they knew her true identity. As for the ancient legends, perhaps it's just to hear stories about dieties and humans that fall and love, and it works out.
That's basically the same thought I had when I read that part..
But it wouldn't be a bad thought to check the original Jap. novels to see if there are any differences..

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 12:09 pm
by Clead
I thought maybe she got some kind of "power" to make the town able to bear pagans, christians and deitys, what I thought is that Bartose was the cenobite but i wasnt sure about what a cenobite was so i just missed that thing. xD

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 1:01 pm
by salv87
Some thoughts we came across at the A-S forum..
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread. ... 43&page=17
Posts 327, 328 and 330

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 1:04 pm
by TheGiftedMonkey
Salv and Clead, welcome to Baka-Tsuki. 8)

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 1:29 pm
by salv87
Thanks TGM ^_^
(Do you mind if I call you like that? just seems everybody else calls you so ^_^)

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 1:36 pm
by TheGiftedMonkey
Haha Yeah I dont mind. You guys find Baka-Tsuki through AS?

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:03 pm
by salv87
I found B-T throug search of Spice and Wolf light novels ^_^
found A-S the same way ^_^

Re: Hey, a question about volume 3..

Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:39 pm
by Clead
Sorry for the late reply.

Thanks TGM, I just arrived to this page thanks to SaW and i want to say thats a very helpful and useful one.

I just say that your avatar is the first thing that I stared in this forum. I like it but didnt see bacanno!.

BTW, the thing about the phil stone may be something interesting, but I continue to think about her relationship with Bartose, I think that will appear in more novels about SaW.
Spoiler! :
In AS board are talking about her managing to create through alchemy the phil stone, so her lover or any human could live eternally

You'll say something about the phil stone changing things into gold, but it seems it can be called elixir of youth or can create it.