Translation Community
http://www.baka-tsuki.org/forums/
Yup, sure. Thanks.Akirina wrote:On the other hand, I've started to finish up DYD v5. larethian, it's ok if I finish up chapter 3, right?
the original japanese isNoa raised her head to look at the man who was gently carrying her. A strong and pleasing face, filled with anger, it looked very strong…
But, like what she had imagined, it was different. The Red-Fingered Claugh Klom that had fought in their battle with Roland, causing the Estabul soldiers to feel fear…
the changes in red are the ones I'd like to make based on the words used in the Japanese version. (changes not in red are just flow of sentence changes as an editor)ノアは自分を軽々と抱きかかえる男を見上げた。精悍な、整った顔立ちに、溢れんぽか
りの怒りをたぎらせている様子は、確かに強そうだったが……
だが、想像していた姿とは、まるで違った。ローランドと戦う、エスタブールの兵たち
全てを恐れ慄かせた、紅指のクラウ・クロム…
(Most paragraphs don't actually have this many changes)Noa looked up at the man who was gently carrying her. A masculine, well featured face, boiling with overflowing anger, he certainly looked very strong, but…
But it was different from what she imagined. The Crimson-Fingered Claugh Klom that had fought in their battle with Roland, causing the Estabul soldiers to tremble in fear…
Actually, I'm translating from the chinese version since I don't know Japanese... And sometimes the phrasing in Chinese seems a little odd... I'd certainly appreciate the help if you could help edit those parts! (and any subsequent translation errors, sorry for the trouble!) Now looking back on it, I realise that I translated Claugh's title wrongly...SapphireSky wrote:Yay! Updates again! Now time to get caught up!
So I've been reading the Japanese alongside of the English translation, currently in vol 3 and I know editors are not really supposed to mess with the translation, but i feel there are some pretty clear places where the translation can be clarified, perhaps because it was translated again from Chinese? Most of the changes I'd like to make (based on my own translation) are word usage and not changing the meaning of the sentence. let me give an example:
original translationthe original japanese isNoa raised her head to look at the man who was gently carrying her. A strong and pleasing face, filled with anger, it looked very strong…
But, like what she had imagined, it was different. The Red-Fingered Claugh Klom that had fought in their battle with Roland, causing the Estabul soldiers to feel fear…the changes in red are the ones I'd like to make based on the words used in the Japanese version. (changes not in red are just flow of sentence changes as an editor)ノアは自分を軽々と抱きかかえる男を見上げた。精悍な、整った顔立ちに、溢れんぽか
りの怒りをたぎらせている様子は、確かに強そうだったが……
だが、想像していた姿とは、まるで違った。ローランドと戦う、エスタブールの兵たち
全てを恐れ慄かせた、紅指のクラウ・クロム…(Most paragraphs don't actually have this many changes)Noa looked up at the man who was gently carrying her. A masculine, well featured face, boiling with overflowing anger, he certainly looked very strong, but…
But it was different from what she imagined. The Crimson-Fingered Claugh Klom that had fought in their battle with Roland, causing the Estabul soldiers to tremble in fear…
All of those corrections are pretty literal and faithful to the original Japanese, so would you approve me making such changes?
Really?Acperience wrote:I'll see about DYD 6, then, but again, no guarantees.
@Akirina: Also, a note, since I think that the project guidelines might've confused you: while I don't know if the Silwest family appears again (aside from in TDYD and OKYD), but just in case for future reference, Silwawest is actually one of the brothers. I've re-translated the sister as Tiilnawest and her nickname as Tiil (and replaced 'Xil' with 'Sil,' to match his name), if that's fine with you?
@SapphireSky: That was translated by Akirina, so that's their decision (just so you don't think I'm ignoring you or anything, aha).
Oops! I do admit that the project guidelines are a little confusing... but I didn't see any sign of the translation for the names of the Silwest family...I'm fine with the re-translation, since I always have trouble when I have to translate the names of places or people... Could you put their names up on the project guidelines as well?According to larethian, Denyuuden has some scenes that weren't mentioned in the anime... But, if you'd like to know what happens after the anime, then you should proceed to Dai Densetsu. Actually, aren't there some animes/mangas like this? I heard Tokage has a prologue in the form of a manga, but the actual series begins in the novels... It'd be really cool if there were a second anime to continue off from Dai Densetsu, though...Arcsol93 wrote:Kind of confused since I started with the anime but basically skip to Dai Densetsu?
On another note this story is really good, never would have thought the first/anime served as the prologue. Pretty cool way to start a story.
Your translations are still really good, considering, it can't be helped if the words aren't the same in Chinese, but the meanings seem spot on. I still have a lot of trouble understanding anything but the most simple sentence structures on my own. Even when I understand all the words, I still don't always know what they're saying so it's good practice for me.Akirina wrote:
Actually, I'm translating from the chinese version since I don't know Japanese... And sometimes the phrasing in Chinese seems a little odd... I'd certainly appreciate the help if you could help edit those parts! (and any subsequent translation errors, sorry for the trouble!) Now looking back on it, I realise that I translated Claugh's title wrongly...
I thought editors
Haha, actually, that translation wasn't done by me... One of the previous translators did the guidelines. I'm fine with it, though.Acperience wrote:Sure! I'll put them under the one-time characters section, since aside from Sil (who's a recurring character in TDYD), I don't know for sure if the other two re-appear.
On the note of names (and I'm sorry, because this one is just me nit-picking): would it be possible to change Reeglewaz/Reez's decided name to Rigwaltz/Rize? Rigwaltz is apparently his name in the anime according to the credits, and it and Rize just look more like actual names to me. xD Not trying to criticize your romanization or anything, since I definitely agree that trying to translate names can be pretty hard (given that I'm just taking these from the anime myself), but yeah.
Ah, sorry. I just assumed. /o\Akirina wrote:Haha, actually, that translation wasn't done by me... One of the previous translators did the guidelines. I'm fine with it, though.Acperience wrote:Sure! I'll put them under the one-time characters section, since aside from Sil (who's a recurring character in TDYD), I don't know for sure if the other two re-appear.
On the note of names (and I'm sorry, because this one is just me nit-picking): would it be possible to change Reeglewaz/Reez's decided name to Rigwaltz/Rize? Rigwaltz is apparently his name in the anime according to the credits, and it and Rize just look more like actual names to me. xD Not trying to criticize your romanization or anything, since I definitely agree that trying to translate names can be pretty hard (given that I'm just taking these from the anime myself), but yeah.
By the way, larethian created viewtopic.php?f=61&t=5455 this for discussion on terminology. Can we create a section for one-time characters or something? It'll make it easier if some of them are recurring.
I've posted chapter 4 already. Thanks!Kuroshiki wrote:Thank you Akirina for DDYD 7 chapter 3 .
I will wait for the chapter 4 before starting to read DDYD 7.
As always, thanks for your hard work, and take your time.
(Started translating some LN in French recently and I now
understand how hard it is . )
YEEEEEEEES \o/I've posted chapter 4 already. Thanks!
Could an editor please do that?Simon wrote:I'd like to request you the ones that want Densetsu no yusha, to create Full Text Pages for the Novels that do not have them. And as I see it, there are multiple volumes that were translated.