Page 1 of 3

New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 5:28 pm
by onizuka-gto
So, when one goes another takes it place, such is the order of things!

As per usual, please list below candidates you think deserves to have this forum, please one candidate, one post only.

From these post i'll pick four to be in the poll, to be voted upon.

This nomination will last 2 weeks. Get posting!

Re: New Forum: The Comrades Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 6:42 pm
by larethian
You locked it....... :lol:

Re: New Forum: The Comrades Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 7:27 pm
by Teh_ping
Actually, the entire CDZ is locked, but registered users can still post for some reason...

Re: New Forum: The Comrades Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 8:19 pm
by onizuka-gto
woops, wrong forum.
Should be okay, inside the news forum.

So start posting.

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 11:41 pm
by Devenk83
Maybe the series who is the most active in the auxiliary brigade forum ? Like this we can have more organisation for the series, and not have everything, including spoiler, in one page.
So it would be...
*Taking a look at the auxiliary brigade forum*
Oh ! Date A Live (I promise that it's simply a coincidence with my taste) with 79 pages in only 2 years. And it's also the most viewed forum.

So for now, I vote Date A Live.

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 11:47 pm
by Misogi
Hmm... To my mind, none of the current projects really need a sub-forum.

I'd rather propose splitting CSR and Index, putting the latter on a "Kamachi-verse" sub-forum that includes all of his series.

If we really have to choose... well, since DAL was added, an alternative would be Golden Time (although it can be put in Toradora's sub-forum).

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 11:58 pm
by larethian
Misogi wrote:Hmm... To my mind, none of the current projects really need a sub-forum.

I'd rather propose splitting CSR and Index, putting the latter on a "Kamachi-verse" sub-forum that includes all of his series.

If we really have to choose... well, since DAL was added, an alternative would be Golden Time (although it can be put in Toradora's sub-forum).
Good ideas. I love to group series by authors.

Devenk83 wrote:Maybe the series who is the most active in the auxiliary brigade forum ? Like this we can have more organisation for the series, and not have everything, including spoiler, in one page.
So it would be...
*Taking a look at the auxiliary brigade forum*
Oh ! Date A Live (I promise that it's simply a coincidence with my taste) with 79 pages in only 2 years. And it's also the most viewed forum.

So for now, I vote Date A Live.
I don't read DAL anymore but it does sound like it can deserve a sub-forum with the activity.

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 12:05 am
by Niflheim
Hmm, could move the seeminlgy inactive series to make room for the more active ones from the Auxiliary Brigades if a lot of requests drop in. That would mean active as in talked about not just runing projects.

As for my nomination, Golden Time.

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 3:03 am
by arczyx
Misogi wrote:I'd rather propose splitting CSR and Index, putting the latter on a "Kamachi-verse" sub-forum that includes all of his series.
Good idea, 100% agree :D

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 3:36 am
by Nurin
Misogi wrote:Hmm... To my mind, none of the current projects really need a sub-forum.

I'd rather propose splitting CSR and Index, putting the latter on a "Kamachi-verse" sub-forum that includes all of his series.
(y) :lol:

And I think it's more for DAL even though Golden Time is not a bad choice.

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 7:37 am
by Devenk83
Well, everyone is divided between Date A Live and Golden Time so...
...

Image

:lol:

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 8:36 am
by Niflheim
A bit early to come to that conclusion but I see your point :P

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 10:52 am
by Misogi
Well, here is what I propose to avoid making too much sub-forums:

- Fusing ZnT with Shana.
- Removing Index from CSR's sub-forum, putting KnS instead.
- Putting Index, Heavy Object, Survey, Zashiki, Survey in a Kamachi-verse sub-forum.
- Fusing Toradora with Golden Time. (Implying to move the sub-forum from the Completed projects.)

Two sub-forums removed, one created, one moved, which leaves room for a new one (likely DAL).

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 11:07 am
by Nurin
Misogi wrote:Well, here is what I propose to avoid making too much sub-forums:

- Fusing ZnT with Shana.
- Removing Index from CSR's sub-forum, putting KnS instead.
- Putting Index, Heavy Object, Survey, Zashiki, Survey in a Kamachi-verse sub-forum.
- Fusing Toradora with Golden Time. (Implying to move the sub-forum from the Completed projects.)

Two sub-forums removed, one created, one moved, which leaves room for a new one (likely DAL).
Me approves, I was planning on propose merging Golden time with Toradora, but I was a little unsure of it myself... Anyway I am for Misogi's Idea :D

Re: New Forum: The Comrades (Series) Nomination

Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 11:15 am
by Niflheim
Why would you want to merge an active project with a finished project?
Also, why noy just move the seemingly inactive projects from the "Active" list all together?