Talk:Seirei Tsukai no Blade Dance
精霊使い=Elementaler? Wouldn't something like Spirit user be a more literal translation? If you have to use elemental I believe word would be Elementalist(s).
I wish other writers have English as half as good as Nasu.
A little request since I'm too lazy =/
Mizuho, are you using Chinese translation? Just that sometimes it looks like there is missing line, or that it is shortened (wellI am judging it only from the memory of reading through part of this with my horrible japanese) --Zuruumi (talk) 19:46, 14 February 2013 (CST)
There're some simplification done to sentences, and he said:
I know I left out some things or changed some things to suit English for comprehension, but I don't think they were consequential.
Please ADD the Epilogue of 'Volume 10 - The Awakening of the Demon King'
Could some one direct me to the page that explains why spirit was changed to elemental. I could find no discussion about the change on the terminology talk page. Just want to know why this change was made. --184.108.40.206 01:16, 16 February 2013 (CST)
I decided it to put consistency with several other naming convention like Elemental Lord, and Elemental Waffe. And, zzhk did the final push for me to do it, http://www.baka-tsuki.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=4633&start=435#p174468 To add on, I've been looking for a term to replace 'spirit contractor' since forever --KuroiHikari (Talk | ) 01:19, 16 February 2013 (CST)
Just a note that "military elemental" would sound awkward, since it would be hard to link "military" to the elements, unlike others like "sword", though I am aware that we can treat the two words as separate and it does not affect reading. Thanks. Zakashi (talk) 03:02, 17 February 2013 (CST)
Militarized means something that has been turned/converted into an object/group belonging to a military. -Anon
If it is guns or other weapons, I think a somewhat common term to use would be "military-grade weapon". So how about something like "tactical class military-grade elementals"? A bit of a mouthful, but to me that capture the meaning well. -Another Anon
They aren't graded in any sense. It's just a simple association to military. Like military aviation, military facilities, military network and etc. --KuroiHikari (Talk | ) 19:27, 23 February 2013 (CST)
So will all instances of "spirit" will be changed to "elemental"? which ones are applicable? In chapter seven "It was a small lizard with its tail on fire. A low level flame spirit." At least in some places, I think Spirit is more appropriate than elemental. SonodaYuki (talk) 04:20, 23 February 2013 (CST)
All instances of spirit will be reverted back to spirit. I'm going with what zzhk proposed for now, keeping elementalist. All changes should be corrected in due time. --KuroiHikari (Talk | ) 04:26, 23 February 2013 (CST)
Hi, just a quick question to do with consistency sake. In volume 1 and 2, I noticed that knee socks nude was used, however in volume 3 naked knee-socks was used instead. I personally prefer the latter, but I would like to know which one would be the more generally preferred one before I make any changes. Thanks for the awesome translations by the way! -- Royaloyalz (talk) 09:15, 27 February 2013 (CST)
Well I don't want to complain since this translation is quite good, but in my opinion changing spirit to elemental is a mistake. Primo: no matter how you look at it seirei is definitely translated as (holy) spirit/ghost, if author would mean elemental he would use yousono or gensono (of course im no expert but thats what my dictionary says;) ). And another matter is that in most rpg systems elemental magic consist only of fire, water, air and earth, but here we have holy/light and darkness too and they're considered different system from 4 elements (or 5 if you prefer Chinese ones).
Your dictionary is using the wrong form of "elemental". 精霊 can easily mean "elemental", as in the fantasy creature. All an elemental is is a spirit of something in the first place, usually nature related but that depends on how the fantasy work in question defines it. So having light, darkness, and swords be part of the scheme, while unusual, is up to the author. The Japanese MTG translations translate "Elemental" to ~の精霊 and the Japanese Wikipedia also lists "Spirit" and "Elemental" as English examples of the word. --EnigmaticRepose (talk) 14:17, 24 July 2013 (CDT)
I´m sorry but i´m new so i dont know if this is the right place for this but the term "Elemental Waffe" seems odd to me since it is a combination of two languages. Is this intentional because of the originals or just something from the Translator? Wouldn´t it be better to make it completely German (Elementare Waffe) or completely English (Elemental Weapon)? --DerDigge (talk) 13:36, 1 March 2013 (CST)
Mixed language terms are considered cool by the majority. And that coolness is common across many cultures --Anon
Well, I'm only certain about the waffe part. I don't know how Elementare is pronounced but the author also uses Elemental Lord, which is English. So, I can only assume Elemental is intended to be English. --KuroiHikari (Talk | ) 17:47, 1 March 2013 (CST)
guessing you tryed the same thing i did, guessing the pattern lol. oh well can't wait till the volume comes out. -Trigger91
I am higly suspecting the date on main page of being wrong. Firstly, it isn´t 25th of Juy yet, but part of Prologue is already translated. Secondly you also claim the correct date to be 25th of June.--Zuruumi (talk) 16:06, 23 July 2013 (CDT)
- Ever heard of pre-releases? It's not rare for authors/publishers to release parts of their work before a release date to stimulate interest. Just be happy about it without nitpicking at every small detail (which FYI is correct). SXIII (talk) 16:16, 23 July 2013 (CDT)
- Yeah, I kinda suspected it might be so, but as this kind of thing rarely ends up being translated I thought it is not so likely. Well it turned out that it was the case. Anyway, although I admit that I made a mistake and I humbly apologize if I have offended anyone of you I don´t see any reason for the agressive tone of your reply. I would certainly be glad to recieve a explanation of where did I make the mistake in phrasing my previous comment, so that I would never do similar mistake again. PS: It just came to me, but if I sounded as if I was complaining about the translation still not being out it was not meant so. It was just literally what I wrote.--Zuruumi (talk) 15:16, 24 July 2013 (CDT)
It is July 25 due to the author getting sick so the released date became a month later. So we just got to wait for translations that will come soon.
Thanks for the explanation. Anyway, I am not in any hurry for the translation. The summer hollidays are long and there is always something to do, so once it is out I will rejoice, but to that time, I will certainly find some other (meaningfull?) activity. Like reading (or rather deciphering) other novels in japanese.--Zuruumi (talk) 15:20, 24 July 2013 (CDT)
Volume 12 release?
- Nobody knows until the publisher decides on one and then tell the public.--Kemm (talk) 15:13, 18 August 2013 (CDT)
- If we looks at the previous release schedule (Feb, May, Aug, Nov) and considering vol 11 out on July I think we can assume vol 12 will be October or November (might be delayed till December or early 2014 though)Shyevsa (talk) 16:56, 18 August 2013 (CDT)
Why in volume one, is Claire and Rinslet's class 'Raven Class', whereas come Volume 12 it's 'Crow Class'?
i read but , i thought this still alike unfinished ?? i cant read Jp word uuuuu... Toojiro [12/30/2013] 18:30
It's me again!!!! and like always does anyone know if the Author or publisher has given the date on the release for Volume 13 yet? Or have they not given it yet?ZAIZEAH
Toojiro idk ~..........
Normally, releases are announced roughly two months in advance.
It's not listed under MF Bunko J's releases for February 2014, so Volume 13 will probably come in March or April barring unexpected delays. By the way, you can sign your posts by typing ~~~~~ (4 tilde signs). --Zzhk (talk) 08:02, 30 December 2013 (CST)
Toojiro thnx a lot !! for the info 12/30/2013 21:17
http://www.baka-tsuki.org/project/index.php?title=Seirei_Tsukai_no_Blade_Dance First Paragraph --KuroiHikari (Talk | ) 06:43, 1 January 2014 (CST)
- spoiler if you haven't read up to ch 9 of vol 5*
Do you guys know if when he releases ppl/ "kill" the elemental lords from the otherworldly darkness will est's curse apply to kamito? Or does the curse only apply to seal armaments and killing spirits/demons? Also who knows about the curse?--Dman21 (talk) 06:33, 31 July 2014 (CDT)
--Light Spoiler-- :P Est did say that her curse would one day end Kamito; the same way it ended her original contractor, thus the reason why she was scared of herself. Kamito still accepted the fact though. The curse is mostly demon spirits, possibly armaments. I believe Est said something about absorbing the taint anyway, thus afflicting the contractor. All Night (talk) 06:57, 31 July 2014 (CDT)
Can someone tell me when the girls find out about Kamito being a part of the instructional school? Never mind found it volume 4 ch. 9-10
I found the answer about 15 minutes after I posted it.Turns out I was looking in the wrong chapter. Felt lazy to delete the topic so I just decided to answer it myself
Volume 14 delay
- Probably because the author is writing six 32-page short stories(I think, since there are a total of 6 BD specials), a total of 192 pages. Comparatively shorter than any of the volumes, but can still eat a lot of time writing one.
About the 32-page short stories
Is there only one short story right now? Wasn't there supposed to be six? Correct me if I'm wrong.
Well, it may not be a leak but instead a preview. Some companies will release a chunk of a book in advance as a preview. Western books do something similar: sometimes at the end of one book in the series you get a chapter from the next book in advance. Anyways, also please sign your future messages using 3 or 4 "~" in a row. I've done it for you this time, it's just good practice.
Yascob (talk) 22:52, 20 February 2017 (CET)
When will Volume 16 be fully translated? There are only 2 chapters and the afterword left, and there hasn't been any update in a month. Seems kinda weird to have barely anything left and leave it there.
GoldenScorpions (talk) 7:27, 28 April 2017 (CEST)
It is most likely due to translator facing RL problems since their other project has not been updated for some time as well. Or that complete raws have not come out( If they are translating from CN version which is first translated from JP to CN then translator translates CN to English ). It hardly matters whatever the case, you may think of it as the novel is yet to come out and come back later when it is updated? Robinhood1 (talk) 08:35, 29 April 2017 (CEST)
Is this series finished?
I was just wondering...... I really want to wait until it concludes before I pick it back up. I really should not procrastinate, seeing as so many companies are DMCA-ing titles now, but I tend to binge read. Appreciate all that you guys do!
I don't know why but... for some reason you put same text on two places on main page: "Blu-Ray Special Stories" and "Volume - Elementalist Festa" are same... why you double it ;) ? --Tuldor88
I want to thank every translator who worked on this series
I'm rather glad this series was picked up and seen through! I really want to thank every translator who worked on this project. I greatly enjoyed your work.
I first read this back in 2013. Now, 7 years later I get to finish it. Thank you.
Hi everyone! seeing as the forums are still locked in the epub/pdf section, i still havnt been able to put in the files there. It would have been nice to at least inform on the BD- site that the actual files with the remaining pdfs are in the discussion forums, however the page is locked.
so a Reminder that the full pdf collection is in the discussion forums :)
Considering how its been many years, and in lieau of the dead facebook pages and fangroups, i wanted to inform that there is an active discord forum about blade dance. https://discord.gg/AGruaz apologies if its considered rude to link here :p
again, this is just to inform, that fans are still alive, although in a smaller number ;) Thanks for everything.